Variant Synonymizer: Platform to identify mutations defined in different ways is available now!

VarSy

Over 2,000 gene–disease validation summaries are now available—no login required!

Browse Summaries

ZCCHC12 – Intellectual Disability

A candidate gene study (PMID:18798319) reported four different sequence variants in SIZN1, now known as ZCCHC12, in 11 affected individuals with nonsyndromic X‑linked mental retardation, suggesting an initial link to intellectual disability (MONDO_0001071). However, subsequent large‑scale exome sequencing investigations (PMID:23871722) revealed a relatively high frequency of truncating variants in control cohorts, leading to significant concerns regarding the specificity of the association. In addition, while functional assays demonstrated that the SUMO interaction motifs in Sizn1 are critical for proper nuclear body localization and transcriptional activation in the BMP signaling pathway (PMID:19416967), directly supporting a plausible molecular mechanism, these in vitro findings have not been definitively linked to the human phenotypic spectrum.

Taken together, although there is experimental support for a functional role of ZCCHC12 in neurodevelopment, the limited genetic evidence from the initial candidate study, counterbalanced by conflicting population data, yields a disputed gene‑disease association. Clinicians should thus interpret ZCCHC12 variants with caution when making diagnostic decisions, while further research is warranted to clarify its role in intellectual disability.

References

  • American journal of medical genetics. Part A • 2008 • Evidence that SIZN1 is a candidate X‑linked mental retardation gene PMID:18798319
  • American journal of human genetics • 2013 • XLID‑causing mutations and associated genes challenged in light of data from large‑scale human exome sequencing PMID:23871722
  • The Journal of biological chemistry • 2009 • SUMO interaction motifs in Sizn1 are required for promyelocytic leukemia protein nuclear body localization and for transcriptional activation PMID:19416967

Evidence Based Scoring (AI generated)

Gene–Disease Association

Disputed

The candidate study identified four distinct sequence variants in 11 probands (PMID:18798319), yet subsequent large-scale exome analysis revealed a relatively high frequency of similar truncating variants in control populations (PMID:23871722), casting doubt on the association.

Genetic Evidence

Limited

Initial genetic findings were based on a small cohort without extensive segregation data, and conflicting population frequency data further weaken the genetic support (PMID:18798319; PMID:23871722).

Functional Evidence

Moderate

Functional assays demonstrated that disruptions in SUMO interaction motifs impaired nuclear localization and transcriptional activation relevant to BMP signaling (PMID:19416967), providing moderate mechanistic support.